Sign In Close close


Forgot Password?

Need To Register? Click Here
 

Showbiz news

Newsletter Sign Up

 

Cover for web


New Bigger Prizes.

Join today and we will double your first deposit as well!

 

Elizabeth Coldwell-Hall and daughter

'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Tuesday 26 August 2008

From the moment Elizabeth Coldwell-Hall fell pregnant, she was determined she would breastfeed. But while the majority of mums wean their babies at around six months old, Elizabeth just kept going.

Astonishingly, the mum-of-four still feeds daughter Andorra – even though she’s nearly five and has a full set of teeth. And she’ll even wet nurse her friends’ babies if they’re too busy to do it themselves.

“I don’t see anything wrong with it– I firmly believe breast is best,” says 42-year-old Elizabeth. “If a friend needs a hand with their babies, I’m always happy to help them out – I’ve got more than enough milk to go round.”

Elizabeth feeds her daughter every day, as well as giving her three solid meals, despite the fact she’ll be starting school full-time in September. 

“She usually crawls into my bed at 6am asking for a feed,” reveals Elizabeth, from Hoyland, South Yorkshire. “But I have to remind her not to bite as it can be painful.”

Elizabeth, a part-time sales assistant, fed her eldest, Felix, now six, until he was 16 months old. Her twins, Mylo and Oscar, two, still breastfeed occasionally, although they have virtually weaned themselves off.

She says: “Felix naturally stopped breastfeeding – he just didn’t want to do it any more. The twins are the same. Now they only feed once or twice a week.

“I was disappointed when they stopped, but it’s their decision. I think Andorra’s carried on because she really enjoys the exclusive ‘mum’ time it gives her. She’ll stop when she’s ready.”

Elizabeth is aware her views are seen as strange by some people, but remains defiant. She says: “Some people might find it disgusting, but no one’s ever said anything to me about it.

“I believe it’s perfectly natural and I don’t care what other people think. I’m doing what’s right for my kids.”

She’s always had the support of husband Craig, 37, an electrician, when it comes to breastfeeding, even though the pair separated four months ago. “He’s never had any qualms about it,” she insists.

Elizabeth is so fired-up about the advantages of breast milk, she’s happy to provide it for her pals’ babies as well. She explains: “My friend’s baby was crying for milk, but her mum was in the middle of doing something, so I offered to feed her. She was delighted, and it was no different to feeding my own child. I’ll happily do it again.
“If a baby needs feeding and I’ve got milk on tap, why not? It doesn’t interfere with the bonding process – being a mother is about much more than that.

“Andorra wasn’t there – but if she had been, she probably would have asked if she could have some afterwards.”

Elizabeth doesn’t normally need to breastfeed Andorra in public now that she’s older, but says she wouldn’t ever rule it out. “If Andorra was upset, or was distressed and wanted comfort I wouldn’t think twice about feeding her in public,” she says. I would be happy to deal with any flak if it’s for my daughter’s benefit.” 

Words by Victoria Raymond
Elizabeth appears in Other People’s Breast Milk on 9 September, 10pm, Channel 4

Posted by Rose-e

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

this is so funny. she is starting school full time soon, what about if she asks the teacher for milk? or wants her mum to breastfeed her? she will get in a tantrum about it if she doesnt get it!

i think child should stop when they are ready yes but if they dont by 16 months i would say no more and give them a flask of it if they wanted any.

Posted 26/08/2008 11:01:32

Posted by charliebeans

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Does this woman realise the potential emotional damage she is doing to her daughter, even if she stopped today. As this girl grows up she will have strong memories of suckling on her mother's breast. She may find this very difficult to deal with especially once she gets to teenage years. Sounds more like a mother's reluctance to let go and allow her daughter to grow up.

Posted 26/08/2008 13:14:41

Posted by scarlett

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

she been watching to much little britain lol

Posted 26/08/2008 14:57:33

Posted by mcball

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

That child is going to have some serious issues when she is older! Kids can be so cruel and once it comes out to her classmates she will be hounded. Poor kid.

Posted 26/08/2008 15:24:54

Posted by pink1976

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I i agree i think she will b made fun of if other kids find out ur right mcball poor kid

Posted 26/08/2008 15:53:36

Posted by amanda8t1

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I think this is wonderful, this mother is giving her child the most natural thing in life!

FACT: The average age a child stops breastfeeding the world over is four years old.
If you consider all the children in Britain that stop at six months old, there must be many children going way past the 'nearly five' mark.

Posted 26/08/2008 19:00:25

Posted by HannieBelle

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

WRONG, WRONG, WRONG!! It's all just wrong!!

Posted 27/08/2008 12:25:22

Posted by longsox

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I think Elizabeth should be praised rather than criticised. She is giving her children the best start in life and allowing them to wean at a time when they feel naturally ready.

I wish our society was more positive towards breast feeding mothers and that people would stop telling us how long we should breast feed, where we should do it and so on. Breast is best.

Posted 27/08/2008 15:50:02

Posted by mable64

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

ITS RIDICULOUS!!!

Posted 27/08/2008 22:25:55

Posted by mable64

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

ITS RIDICULOUS!!!

Posted 27/08/2008 22:26:04

Posted by shopaholic97

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

stuipid stuipid stiipid is this wumun mental??????

Posted 28/08/2008 19:04:06

Posted by sammilidd

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

i honestly dont think theres anything wrong with breastfeeding she not hurting anybody in the process so fair do's to ya love and who are we to cast an opinion of what this woman should be doing there her kids and if there nt ready there nt ready leave her alone

Posted 29/08/2008 08:43:15

Posted by sammilidd

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

i honestly dont think theres anything wrong with breastfeeding she not hurting anybody in the process so fair do's to ya love and who are we to cast an opinion of what this woman should be doing there her kids and if there nt ready there nt ready leave her alone

Posted 29/08/2008 08:43:18

Posted by charliebeans

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'


Do the people who believe that putting a 3, 4 or 5 year to their mother's breast is best have any knowledge of child psychology? I somehow doubt it! If they are determined to continue to feed their children breast milk then they can always express it - sparing their child of future emotional problems. These woman always seem to have a problem with letting go, letting their child grow up. Although perhaps a little harsh their treatment of their child is almost child abuse! These are growing children NOT giant babies!

Posted 29/08/2008 17:07:15

Posted by pink-kissess

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

lol.. i think the words BITTY come to mind!

little britain springs to mind,

Posted 02/09/2008 08:23:32

Posted by aniee1986

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Logically this musdt be natural as if it wasnt she wouldnt be able to do it - sociaety has such a negative view of breastfeeding - i think its because we have been trained to think of breasts as sexual things rather than what they are made for - i say each to their own her other children have weaned themselves so her daughter will eventually - all those who have posted negative comments are clearly closed minded

Posted 02/09/2008 11:46:27

Posted by chelle82

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

surely this is a from of sexual abuse, as this child is far to old to be doing somthing like this!... and if that was my friend askin if i wanted them to feed my baby with there milk... i dnt think they would be my friend anymore.... its DISCUSTING!!!!

Posted 02/09/2008 12:24:36

Posted by tiny tina

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

i think its stupid . the child will end up too dependent on her mum i think shes makin her rod for her own back

Posted 02/09/2008 12:39:48

Posted by charliebeans

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Dear Aniee1986
I think accusing those of having a closed mind speaks volumes about your own mind. Breastfeeding is a wonderful thing for BABIES. However babies grow, physically and emotionally and that is where my concern lies. Try reading some child psychology and you will begin to understand the emotional damage this child is being subjected to.

Posted 02/09/2008 13:00:57

Posted by Heidi Wilke

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Quite a few years ago in this society, any form of breast feeding (even to tiny infants) was considered 'disgusting' - just as this woman is accused of being here. In many other countries, especially in Africa and Asia, children are offered the breast when they are distressed until they are seven or eight years old - are all you who are criticising this woman suggesting that these children from other cultures are being 'abused' either sexually or emotionally? In fact it is this that has probably saved lots of children from dying, either from unhygienic water or lack of food. It is culturally acceptable in their society and it isn't here - and that's the big difference. This country needs to open its mind up to the fact that breast feeding is a good thing. I gave up breast feeding when my daughter was 4 months old because I was getting fed up with the looks and comments I was getting. It's this society that is disgusting, not the women who try to feed their children in the most natural way.

Posted 02/09/2008 19:04:41

Posted by mrssmudger8442

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

there are many benefits to breast milk and as long as the child will drink it that is probably best but why not express it? all the benefits without the teasing from other kids and any psychological damage from being overly attached to mum. there are other ways of giving a young girl exclusive mum time! i have always thought if a child is old enough to walk to the fridge themselves then it is probably time to wean them off breast feeding.

Posted 03/09/2008 08:38:14

Posted by saffy

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Absolutely disgusting,the woman is a perv

Posted 04/09/2008 11:16:40

Posted by Lauren Packer

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

this is bang out of order, its sick...having a kid that big still sucking your breasts is just wrong?! i dont know know anyone can see anything right with it, that child is guna b well messed up in the long run!

Posted 06/09/2008 01:46:35

Posted by closertost

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

each to their own, but i dont think breast feeding your friends babys should be encouraged at all, as there are potential health risks. i also think that its more the fact the mother dosent want to let go of the child, not the other way round, children sucking bottles at five would be frowned on this is the same, let these children start to grow up and give them the independence they need at this age .

Posted 07/09/2008 00:48:24

Posted by jowatts

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I know they say breast is best and to give your child the best start in life, well at 5 I think you can safely say she has had it ten fold.
I think its weird and I think the mother don't want to let go.
As for wet nursing NO NO NO.
I would never let my kid suck on another womans breast unless it was a life or death situation.

Posted 16/09/2008 12:46:35

Posted by chelle82

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I just cant get over how discusting this is!... Hand that rocks the cradel comes to mind!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted 16/09/2008 14:17:12

Posted by cerise08

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

it's understandable they do say when the child is ready to stop breast feeding he/she will stop. it does make the child have a higher iq and prevents them from many sicknesses.

Posted 16/09/2008 22:39:09

Posted by _michelle_d_x

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

wow - that kid is gona have no friends when she goes to high school maybe primary schools okay but --- poor girl ! x

Posted 08/10/2008 22:09:56

Posted by charlottelucy

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

It seems from what the mother is saying, that the child only does it for 'mum time', so technically she does not require the milk for any reason other then attention which is as unhealthy a reason to let her do it as the suckling itself!

It's all very well stating that she doesn't care what other people say about it but just because her body is still making milk doesn't mean she has to keep letting the child suckle it - why doesn't she just take her four year old to the park for 'mum time' and let her have some HEALTHY exercise and fresh air filled 'mum time'!!

Posted 15/10/2008 09:43:51

Posted by naomi.brown89

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Not being funny but if she doesnt care what people think-why would she write in to a magazine where you know there are going to be mixed opinions. I was bottle fed-and i turned out just fine!! So breast can be best but not when your child is five! It does not take 4 years to wean a child off of breast-feeding! I think she may have problems with her daughter growing up and i agree with you Rose-e what are her teachers going to do if she asks for a feed?!

Msg to people who think this is fine-what age do you think children should be when their mothers stop breast-feeding them? Not saying that in a nasty way just wonder what your opinion is.

Posted 22/10/2008 16:23:38

Posted by amanda8t1

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Well Naomi scientifically the childs sucking reflex disappears around 7 or 8 years old, so neither mum or child as a choice, they must finish by then.

Posted 23/10/2008 19:38:48

Posted by staceyk

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I understand the benefits but enough is enough. Let the girl grow up.x

Posted 24/10/2008 15:59:08

Posted by Kirstenh =]

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I dont think its disgusting. But I think It would be a good idea if she like..used a breast pump so she doesnt need to physically breast feed her. And then her daughter might not end up with psychological discomfort. It makes so much more sense to me! Dont ya think? x

Posted 03/11/2008 17:25:04

Posted by PerrinA

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Bitty Bitty!!! lol well fair play it's her kid and it's up to her...I know for a fact that by that age they don't need the breast milk anymore..I work in Maternity...so yeah breastfeeding is a fantastic way to bond and does give your child the best start in life but please...she'll be starting full time education soon...when will it end?

If bullied at school at 12/13 will you offer her a breast as comfort?

But, like I said...your decision...

Posted 06/11/2008 23:05:11

Posted by sarah101

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Im a female who firmly believes in the benifits of breastfeeding however theres always one nutjob who'l take it to the extremes. This selfish delusional woman needs to wake up to the consequences of this on that poor little girl. And what sort of mother allows her child to be breast fed by another woman just because shes caught up in something?!!! Crazy crazy ppl . . . . .

Posted 10/11/2008 22:19:18

Posted by bububu

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

she dose not want her child to grow up by the looks of things its discusting

Posted 09/01/2009 22:22:24

Posted by natd

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

omgggg what the hell! shes five years old. she starts skool soon and is going to get bulied over you. do you really want that for your kid. this is so wrong man. even if you dont want to grow up that not really your decicion tbf. so bad !!!

Posted 03/04/2009 10:16:10

Posted by ****

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

if she wipped her boob out in front of me
then i think i wuld slap her
breastfeeding a 5 yr old sick

Posted 19/05/2009 14:43:25

Posted by traci

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

this child should be sitting at the table with a knife and fork like a normal child, there are some right wierdo's in this world, and it's always the kid's that suffer in the long run.

Posted 03/06/2009 00:23:59

Posted by Sammie

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

sorry but all i can think of is bitty!!

Posted 13/07/2009 13:56:36

Posted by kerry girl

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

thats just f*n wrong..... its like sumfin off little britain ( i want bitty) errrrrrrr! as if wen shes older n she has her 1st boyfriend shes guna suck on her moms boob 4 her dinna lol its just sick!!!!

Posted 16/07/2009 16:26:49

Posted by boo:D

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

that is actual sick!!!
whether you dont wanna let go or what u got wake up to reality!
she is gonna be bullied n humiliated at school... but it will be all ur fault
SICK

Posted 23/10/2009 14:38:32

Posted by tixxylixxy

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

im not quite getting this ....she has weaned her younger children off breastfeeding but not her five year old?
its just not right of normal

Posted 02/11/2009 05:09:05

Posted by Rosie Pea

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Can any of the people supporting this woman REMEMBER being breastfed? Just think for a minute, actually picture this, sitting across your mummy's knee and sucking her nipple. Imagine if you could vividly remember that! I am all for breastfeeding, as it is proven to have health benefits for the baby, but imagine the psychological effects the MEMORIES of being breastfed would have. I imagine this child is going to lead an incredibly sheltered life and the bizarre bond she has formed with her mother has the potential to affect her ability to cope in social situations and future relationships.

Posted 05/01/2010 13:47:09

Posted by jenniferscamblerx

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

if her daughter wants breast milk pump it and give her it in a blooming cup ? she is 5 years old for god sake ! i could no imagine my 5 year old going anywere near my bloody boob . Its horrid , to be honest that child will turn 12 - 13 , and remeber ? and be like why did my mum breast feed me untill then . I dont think it is natural , shes a wee girl , not a baby , she can feed herself , get ready herself , let your daughter grow up

Posted 09/08/2010 01:55:14

Posted by GEMMA HOLMES

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

I still breastfeeed my nine year old, i had her when i was 12 and i cant baare her to be away from my brests besides the feelings quite nice hehe

Posted 23/09/2010 14:16:14

Posted by Morag Gaherty

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

As it happens, I know this lady and her children, and not one of them is sick or delusional. Her point was that her daughter came to her for comfort feeding in the morning, not that she was not feeding her food! it was for Andorra to choose when to give up (as she later did) and nothing at all to do with wanting to hold on to her.

As for all this nonsense about the daughter being bullied at school, well why would that happen? Do you think breastfeeding would be her choice of conversation in the playground, or are you suggesting that one of the other parents would "out" her for not conforming to the usual norms, so that word would get round - no doubt "for her own good." That's called bullying, you know.

Oh, and our society didn't use to be squeamish about wet nursing - most
wealthy women used to hand their child on to be fed by a wet nurse. It's just not what people are used to now, so therefore it must be wrong.

And finally, in response to all you amateur psychologists out there: Andorra has a much wider social life than most kids out there, because one thing her mum DOESN'T do is shelter her. How many of you let your own kids play without parental control at all stages? Not many, I bet.

Posted 07/11/2010 11:25:37

Posted by Think_About_It

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

first of all i would like to say im a man just to distinguish myself from all the moms on here. so i dont see anything wrong with this as the fact of the matter is its her child. most of us were breast fed at sometime so its not that disgusting just because the child is bigger then the small infant you were use to breast feeding or think of in the generic breast feeding idea being a small infant. also if any of you who say this is mentally going to scar the child let me ask you something can you remember anything when you were five because i know i cant so to say this child will is goofy most people have trouble remembering what they ate last week let alone the first five years of there life

Posted 07/08/2011 04:03:58

Posted by Think_About_It

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

first of all i would like to say im a man just to distinguish myself from all the moms on here. so i dont see anything wrong with this as the fact of the matter is its her child. most of us were breast fed at sometime so its not that disgusting just because the child is bigger then the small infant you were use to breast feeding or think of in the generic breast feeding idea being a small infant. also if any of you who say this is mentally going to scar the child let me ask you something can you remember anything when you were five because i know i cant so to say this child will is goofy most people have trouble remembering what they ate last week let alone the first five years of there life

Posted 07/08/2011 04:04:04

Posted by ashes49

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

i think this woman is doing a great job at giving her children whats best for them, no one has the right to criticise assge is not forcing the child to breastfeed, like her other children she is waithing for her daughter to give it up herself.

Posted 24/12/2011 15:27:23

Posted by Quew

RE: 'I'm still breastfeeding my five year old'

Let the baby become a child and make the mother become an adult. Just who wants who? More to the point... what is missing from their lives that they feel so insecure and can't let go?

Posted 28/12/2011 22:17:04



Comments

 
Visit our shop
Closer Competitions!